“Looking back, on this case, understanding what I do know now, I want I had issued a stop-work order in that case…till the ice was cleared”
Article content material
A Ministry of Labour inspector who made two website visits to the Claridge Icon constructing website within the weeks earlier than Olivier Bruneau was killed in 2016 stated he would have issued a “stop-work” order if he had an opportunity for a “do-over.”
Commercial 2
Article content material
Bruneau, a 24-year-old format carpenter with Bellai Brothers, was killed on March 23, 2016, when he was struck by a four-metre, 56-kg slab of falling ice that broke away from the south wall of the 30-metre excavation pit within the Little Italy space.
Article content material
His father, Christian Bruneau, advised the inquest into his son’s dying on Wednesday that one query has haunted him since that day.
He requested ministry inspector Brent Tureski why he determined to depart it to the employer to take “acceptable motion” to take away ice from the partitions after the hazard had beforehand been recognized on the building website.
“Looking back, on this case, understanding what I do know now, I want I had issued a stop-work order in that case…till the ice was cleared,” Tureski stated throughout Bruneau’s cross-examination.
Commercial 3
Article content material
“I consider that this will have made it a bit extra formidable to the employer to maintain up their process of eradicating the ice and never stopping (the ice removing).”
Tureski testified over two days and advised the inquest that he had been known as to the positioning by Claridge foreman Mike Lwow to analyze an incident the day past wherein a employee was struck by falling ice.
When he first arrived for an inspection on Feb. 5, 2016, Tureski parked behind the Clear Water Works vans and realized from Claridge that the corporate had been contracted to blast the ice away with scorching water.
The ministry inspector visited the Claridge website however didn’t converse with that employee, Anthony Home, who beforehand testified that he was struck on his again and shoulder by falling ice on Feb. 4.
Commercial 4
Article content material
Home wasn’t severely injured however advised the inquest that he refused to return to the positioning and requested a switch to a different job.
Tureski stated Wednesday that the harm to Home was not extreme sufficient to set off a compulsory investigation and didn’t meet the factors for a “reportable” harm.
Tureski issued no orders associated to the ice in the course of the website go to, the inquest has heard.
He did subject one quotation to a Bellai Brothers website supervisor, Leo Simard, for having an open flame within the firm trailer.
Tureski stated he extinguished the burner himself and issued the “forthwith order,” which means the violation had been remedied earlier than he left.
“On the time, with the data I had and with what I noticed, I discussed the burner (within the subject report) because the extra potential hazard on the time.”
Commercial 5
Article content material
Tureski advised Bruneau’s father that he didn’t consider his investigation would have been altered by an interview with Home.
He stated he met with Lwow and one other website supervisor and, from that dialog, Tureski believed “it was clear” the ice needed to be eliminated for the job to proceed.
-
Ice ‘needed to be eliminated’ from Claridge Icon work website, ministry inspector tells Bruneau inquest
-
‘It may have been prevented’ fellow employee testifies at Olivier Bruneau inquest
The supervisors appeared “excited” over the answer to blast the ice away with scorching water, Tureski stated, they usually additionally mentioned erecting a barrier or fence to maintain employees away from the “no-go zone” close to the south wall.
“The very fact of the matter was, it was being compiled with, and it was my expectation that (ice removing) would proceed,” Tureski advised the inquest.
Commercial 6
Article content material
The ice removing didn’t proceed on the website, the inquest has heard, because the contract with Clear Water Works was cancelled in late February.
Underneath questioning from Bruneau’s father, Tureski acknowledged the one point out of ice in his subject report from that day was a notation that he had “mentioned procedures taken by constructor to stop a reoccurrence.”
That “process” he referenced was the removing of the ice, the inspector stated.
Tureski made a second go to to the positioning on Feb. 24, 4 weeks earlier than the deadly incident, however stated he didn’t comply with up on the conversations he had on the earlier go to.
He was visiting the positioning with a ministry engineer to examine a crane and stated he didn’t recall making any observations of ice formations on the partitions on that second go to.
Commercial 7
Article content material
When requested by a ministry lawyer whether or not he had any suggestions to recommend for the jury to stop additional tragedies, Tureski stated he had been interested by that query as he tuned in to the earlier seven days of the inquest.
“Throughout the inquest, I’ve heard quite a lot of instances that ice was falling, not simply in February however in early January as nicely,” Tureski replied.
“I consider that if falling ice was a prescribed notifiable occasion (beneath the Occupational Well being and Security Act) then we wouldn’t have had any points with anyone getting harm by the ice. We might have been notified lengthy upfront and handled the scenario a lot earlier.”
ahelmer@postmedia.com
Twitter.com/helmera
