Non-public med providers get gov’t money regardless of billing allegation: Report

Article content material

The B.C. authorities has doled out no less than $393 million to for-profit personal surgical procedure and medical imaging firms since 2015 to supply providers throughout the public system, all whereas overlooking illegal billing practices, in keeping with a brand new report by the Canadian Centre for Coverage Alternate options’ B.C. department.

Article content material

Critics say that’s making a de facto two-tier system through which wealthier British Columbians will pay for quicker medical remedy.

Article content material

The report comes at a time when B.C.’s health-care system is crumbling amid quick staffing and a household physician scarcity, and when the talk round personal well being care has ramped up following final month’s B.C. Supreme Courtroom determination round additional billing that’s doubtless headed to the Supreme Courtroom of Canada.

Well being coverage analyst Andrew Longhurst’s report, launched Wednesday, reveals the province’s well being authorities have paid hundreds-of-millions of {dollars} to for-profit personal clinics identified to have engaged in additional billing, an illegal apply through which clinics invoice sufferers privately for medically needed procedures which can be already coated by the general public health-care system underneath the Medical Companies Plan. This method, Longhurst mentioned, permits wealthier sufferers to leap the queue by paying privately for needed well being care.

Article content material

Longhurst discovered the for-profit sector has benefited from elevated outsourcing of publicly funded procedures due to lengthy ready lists for surgical procedures within the public system. The Well being Ministry has upped its spending on personal clinics by 57 per cent since 2015-16, in keeping with the report, referred to as: “The Regarding Rise of Company Drugs.”

B.C. has 14 personal MRI clinics, through which sufferers will pay round $1,000 for medical-imaging. MRIs are exempt from B.C.’s Medicare Safety Act. There are additionally 45 personal surgical clinics working within the province.

Longhurst mentioned the B.C. authorities continues to be contracting with a number of personal surgical clinics which were audited over their extra-billing practices. For instance, False Creek Surgical Centre, one of many largest personal clinics in B.C., obtained $12.2 million in well being authority funds between 2015-16 and 2020-21 regardless of a latest B.C. authorities audit that discovered the clinic engaged in additional billing, the report mentioned. The clinic was acquired by a Toronto personal funding agency, Kensington Capital Advisers, in 2019.

Article content material

In accordance with a September 2019 e-mail change between the previous proprietor of False Creek clinic and Deputy Minister of Well being Stephen Brown, obtained by Longhurst by way of a Freedom of Data request, the proprietor expresses his appreciation that the provincial authorities will present “long-term, quantity assured contracts which can allow us to make an knowledgeable determination on the long-term sustainability of this enterprise mannequin.”

Well being Minister Adrian Dix careworn he’s been a long-time champion of the general public well being system and mentioned solely three per cent of publicly funded surgical procedures — 13,000 out of the 340,000 surgical procedures carried out a yr in B.C. — are executed in personal clinics.

Dix mentioned the province has practically doubled the variety of publicly funded MRIs in three years from 170,000 to 300,000, which he referred to as a “thoughts blowing” improve, and acquired three personal surgical clinics to extend surgical capability.

Article content material

Relating to the False Creek Surgical Centre, Vancouver Coastal Well being ended the contract with them in 2018 and solely restarted it when the newly owned clinic modified its practices to adjust to B.C. legal guidelines, Dix mentioned.

The Well being Ministry introduced in April that Island Well being spent $11.5 million to buy two personal surgical centres in Higher Victoria and Nanaimo with a view to improve the variety of surgical procedures and endoscopies obtainable to Vancouver Island residents.

Ontario is eyeing personal clinics as the important thing to decreasing surgical ready lists. Final week, Doug Ford’s Conservative authorities introduced it would improve publicly coated surgical procedures at personal clinics.

Whereas contracting-out to non-public medical providers could take strain off the general public system within the short-term, it additionally has long-term penalties, Longhurst mentioned. It exacerbates employees shortages by luring health-care employees away from the general public system by way of higher pay, he mentioned.

Article content material

Analysis reveals personal medical providers are extra pricey and fail to cut back ready occasions over the long-term. For instance, the report analyzed the price of knee surgical procedures for injured employees by way of WorkSafeBC and located they value practically 4 occasions extra in a non-public clinic — $3,222 — in contrast with $859 in a public hospital.

B.C. Inexperienced celebration MLA Adam Olsen mentioned the erosion of the province’s public health-care system has created the ecosystem for personal clinics to thrive, which is “very regarding.”

“Now they’ll cost a premium for the service that they’re offering as a result of the federal government’s determined,” Olsen mentioned. “Not solely does it put the common, equitable health-care system in danger, it really signifies that (the federal government is) paying a premium for providers that it ought to be delivering itself.”

Article content material

In July, the B.C. Courtroom of Enchantment’s three justices have been unanimous that the province’s ban on medical doctors’ additional billing and limits to non-public medical health insurance don’t violate the Structure. Nevertheless, the justices additionally acknowledged that persons are struggling and dying from ready too lengthy for needed medical care.

The case, which is probably going headed to the Supreme Courtroom of Canada, was introduced by Dr. Brian Day of the Cambie Surgical procedure Centre and argued that regulated personal surgical providers and personal medical health insurance may take strain off the general public system and supply a “security valve” to sufferers dealing with lengthy waits.

Dix in February requested the Medical Companies Fee to look into complaints about Telus’s LifePlus Program and different personal fee-based providers to find out whether or not such providers create a two-tier system that permits some to leap the queue. That overview is full however hasn’t but been made public. 

kderosa@postmedia.com

Extra information, fewer advertisements: Our in-depth journalism is feasible because of the assist of our subscribers. For simply $3.50 per week, you may get limitless, ad-lite entry to The Vancouver Solar, The Province, Nationwide Submit and 13 different Canadian information websites. Help us by subscribing right this moment: The Vancouver Solar | The Province.