Bochra Manaï believes town has come a great distance within the two years since she was employed. “We’re in a distinct place,” she says.

Article content material
Montreal’s anti-racism commissioner was a 10-year-old refugee when she first acquired referred to as a “sale Arabe,” or soiled Arab.
Commercial 2
Article content material
It was Bochra Manaï’s first day of faculty in Paris, in October 1992. Months earlier, she had fled Tunisia together with her mom and 4 siblings to hitch her father in France. That they had spent two months in Algeria, which was within the midst of a civil battle, and three days within the worldwide zone on the airport in Paris, after her mom requested political asylum throughout a stopover on a flight to Vienna.
Article content material
Her mother and father had been in growing hazard in Tunisia, as dissidents to the burgeoning dictatorship of president Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali. Their residence was underneath surveillance. Her brother had been imprisoned, her sister expelled from faculty.
As Manaï stood in entrance of her new classroom in Paris, the instructor requested her classmates to introduce themselves. One lady — “Francesca, I nonetheless keep in mind her identify,” Manaï mentioned — refused, occurring a tirade about “soiled Arabs.”
Commercial 3
Article content material
Two issues prevented Manaï from being scarred by the incident. First, her instructor took cost of the state of affairs and took Manaï underneath her wing, holding her throughout recess for the subsequent a number of months to assist her catch as much as the remainder of the category; by the top of the yr, she was among the many high college students. Second, her mom was outraged when she realized what occurred, and informed Manaï to by no means let herself be insulted or intimidated by others.
The expertise, which Manaï calls her “first date with racism,” set her on a life path of lecturers and activism that led her to earn two grasp’s levels — one in city geography and one other in inter-ethnic relations — and a PhD in city research from Montreal’s Institut nationwide de la recherche scientifique. She labored for 2 years as director of Montreal North anti-poverty group Parole d’excluEs earlier than being named town’s first commissioner on racism and systemic discrimination, in 2021.
Commercial 4
Article content material
To mark the second anniversary of her hiring, on Jan. 18, the Montreal Gazette talked to Manaï about her journey, and her first two years on the job.

She was greeted by an uproar. Manaï was named to the place following a months-long search by town in response to suggestions from the Workplace de session publique de Montréal in June 2020 that discovered town had turned “a blind eye” to systemic racism and discrimination inside its forms and the police pressure.
A spokesperson for Premier François Legault mentioned her appointment was “questionable given her stance on previous points” and “a mistake” by Montreal’s administration. In 2019, Manaï, a spokesperson for the Nationwide Council of Canadian Muslims, had been concerned within the authorized problem to Invoice 21, Quebec’s secularism legislation.
Commercial 5
Article content material
Balarama Holness, whose group Montréal en Motion spurred the report from town’s session physique that resulted within the creation of her put up, mentioned Manaï’s hiring was a missed alternative and signal of “anti-Blackness” by the mayor’s Projet Montréal social gathering, since Manaï isn’t from the Black neighborhood.
She was prepared for the outcry.
“I used to be serene,” Manaï mentioned. “I knew it was going to be a tough journey. However I had a lot help.”
Talking in her defence on the time, Mayor Valérie Plante mentioned it was “a really rigorous course of, and Mme Manaï went by all of the completely different assessments. She’s acquired a number of expertise on the sphere but additionally her tutorial information are fairly spectacular. So we imagine she’s going to be capable of take us to a different stage.
Commercial 6
Article content material
“It’s about all of the completely different divisions, the alternative ways we work on the metropolis of Montreal, hiring, every thing might be going by her evaluation so we convey extra range, so we’re extra conscious and preventing any sort of discrimination on the metropolis of Montreal.”
Manaï obtained a tidal wave of encouragement from associates and colleagues, and most essential, unconditional help from her quick boss, Montreal metropolis supervisor Serge Lamontagne.
“In lower than a month, he took me on a tour of administration,” she mentioned. “I met all of the leaders and managers for town, and he mentioned, ‘I selected Bochra for such and such causes. You’re going to be challenged, however we’re going to do it, and we’re going to do it respectfully.’”
Commercial 7
Article content material
They spent a lot of the previous 24 months conducting an entire overhaul of human sources throughout all metropolis departments, organizations and boroughs to make every thing from the hiring course of to day-to-day operations extra equitable and inclusive.
“It’s a must to like pace (on this job); it goes quick,” Manaï mentioned. “And you must like working with completely different individuals. I work with service administrators, and I lead workshops in boroughs with blue collar staff and foremen. Town is 28,000 workers.
“It’s desirous about tradition, offering companies, roadwork, all these individuals should be sensitized to matters of racism and discrimination. You might have to have the ability to navigate between completely different vocabularies. … It’s a must to settle for that there are individuals who don’t find out about these matters, or who simply don’t give a rattling.”
Commercial 8
Article content material
How does she reply to such resistance?
“It’s a must to talk that it’s an organizational stance,” she mentioned. “It’s a must to clarify to those that town determined this. The municipal administration determined this. And we’re going to get there collectively. Over the previous two years, I feel I’ve proven that I work with respect — we’re not right here to mess around, however we are going to transfer ahead whereas taking everybody by the hand, and we received’t neglect anybody.”
Manaï is wanting on the lengthy recreation. Whereas it could be onerous at this stage for the common citizen to watch the tangible outcomes of such inside tinkering, she says it’s the one means for town to maneuver on to tackling the larger points with the intention to result in lasting change. That breadth of imaginative and prescient is a part of what acquired her employed.
Commercial 9
Article content material
“I confirmed my colors from the beginning,” Manaï recalled. “I mentioned, ‘Crucial factor within the first few years is human sources, as a result of in the event you don’t work on human sources and also you don’t diversify the troops, in the event you don’t assessment how complaints are handled internally, in the event you don’t revise your insurance policies — like our coverage of respect of the particular person, or our code of conduct — if we don’t replace the DNA of the group, whether or not we’re speaking about racial profiling, tradition or citizen participation, we received’t get there. As a result of the DNA of the group has to accompany individuals on this transformation.”
Human sources, she notes, entails every thing from recruitment to coaching and promotions. The last word objective is for racialized and non-racialized workers to have the identical possibilities not solely of being employed however of shifting up by town’s numerous departments. And for racialized Montrealers to have the ability to take a look at their boroughs and see individuals like them employed in any respect ranges. Acquiring such an end result requires an entire structural transformation of human sources citywide.
Commercial 10
Article content material

Amongst her proudest accomplishments of the previous two years, Manaï lists: working with the Ville-Marie borough in 2021 on a plan for fairness, range and inclusion; a six-month initiative with town’s 911 operators in 2022 to make sure that prejudices expressed by some callers don’t get handed on to the cops despatched to reply to a disaster; and accompanying town’s human sources division in guaranteeing the variety of the choice committee that in November selected Montreal’s new reform-minded police chief, Fady Dagher.
Whereas she kept away from providing her private opinion on Dagher’s appointment, Manaï acknowledged that the previous Longueuil police chief’s monitor file speaks for itself.
“I feel he has demonstrated elsewhere what he’s able to,” she mentioned. “We’re a metropolis with a police pressure upon which there are a number of expectations. And as Bochra the anti-racism commissioner, I’m reassured to know that the challenges of the approaching years might be shouldered by somebody like him. He has the expertise but additionally the imaginative and prescient. And I feel he’s somebody who listens. That’s extraordinarily essential.”
Commercial 11
Article content material
Final March town introduced 12 objectives for the approaching yr, together with making a division chargeable for range inside its human sources division, making it simpler for metropolis workers to file complaints, persevering with efforts to remove racial and social profiling by police, combatting hate crimes, selling hyperlinks with Indigenous communities, guaranteeing extra range in festivals and cultural occasions, overcoming inequalities between neighbourhoods and preventing housing discrimination.
This coming March, Manaï and representatives from numerous municipal departments will present an replace on town’s progress on these points. That accountability course of is a key element of town’s engagement to residents, Manaï says.
Commercial 12
Article content material
“I see it as a approach to mobilize town’s companies, administrators and professionals to say to Montrealers, ‘Right here is your public service. Your public service is now able to talking about racism and systemic discrimination.’”
Whereas she wouldn’t go into element about what might be introduced, Manaï believes Montreal has come a great distance in two years.
“We’re in a distinct place,” she mentioned. “There’s a willingness to collaborate on the a part of all metropolis companies. Originally, I feel individuals wanted to know who I used to be and to construct belief. Right now, there’s little question that belief is there.”
-
Montreal’s new anti-racism commissioner Bochra Manaï addresses her critics
-
Hanes: Bochra Manaï’s critics ought to take a tough look within the mirror
-
Montreal’s report card on anti-racism efforts panned by critics